The short answer
There is no single, universally agreed best player in fencing. If the measure is Olympic medals, the Italian épée and foil fencer Edoardo Mangiarotti is the name most often put first, with 13 Olympic medals, six of them gold. If the measure is Olympic gold medals in a single weapon, the Hungarian sabre fencer Aladár Gerevich, with seven golds across six consecutive Games, is a leading candidate. For women’s fencing, the Italian foil fencer Valentina Vezzali, with six Olympic golds, is the name most often cited.
The names most often given
- Edoardo Mangiarotti (Italy). Most Olympic medals in fencing history, won in épée and foil, plus many world championship medals.
- Aladár Gerevich (Hungary). Seven Olympic gold medals in sabre, including team golds spread over a span of nearly 30 years.
- Valentina Vezzali (Italy). Six Olympic golds and nine Olympic medals in foil, including three consecutive individual titles.
- Nedo Nadi (Italy). Credited with six Olympic golds, five of them at the 1920 Games, across all three weapons.
- Pál Kovács and Rudolf Kárpáti (Hungary). Each credited with six Olympic golds in sabre.
Among more recent champions, Lee Kiefer in women’s foil and Áron Szilágyi in men’s sabre are often cited as modern greats, each with multiple Olympic titles.
Why there is no single answer
A few things keep the debate open:
- Era. Early champions faced smaller fields and different rules, so a medal count does not mean the same thing across a century.
- Weapon. Foil, épée and sabre reward different strengths, which makes cross-weapon comparison subjective.
- Metric. Olympic medals, world titles, years at the top and influence on the sport all lead to different rankings.
A fair way to answer is to say who is the best in a particular weapon and period, rather than naming one person for all time. For a longer treatment, including modern stars and American fencers, see the best fencers of all time.
Best right now
“Best right now” is a different question, answered by current rankings and recent results rather than career totals. The FIE rankings change through the season, so check them directly; who are the top fencers in the world explains how, and the FIE World Cup circuit and world rankings covers how the points work.
Learn more
If watching the greats makes you want to try competing, start with how fencing tournaments work.