Penalties and Referees

Cheating in Fencing: Famous Scandals and How It's Caught

What cheating looks like in fencing, the 1976 Onishchenko épée scandal, how weapon checks and referees catch it, and what penalties offenders face.

On this page
  1. What counts as cheating in fencing
  2. The Onishchenko scandal, Montreal 1976
  3. Controversies that are not cheating
  4. How officials catch cheating
  5. What happens to a fencer caught cheating
  6. What is not allowed in fencing
  7. Cheating in other sports

What counts as cheating in fencing

Because fencing relies on electronic scoring, most serious cheating involves equipment. Other forms are about conduct: deliberately breaking the rules to gain an advantage, or behaving dishonestly toward officials. Typical examples include:

  • Tampering with a weapon or wiring so it registers touches that did not happen
  • Using equipment that does not meet the rules
  • Misleading the referee about a touch or a result
  • Unsportsmanlike or violent conduct that goes beyond ordinary rule breaking

Not every rules violation is cheating. A fencer who steps off the strip by mistake or arrives with a faulty piece of kit has broken a rule, but is usually handled with a routine penalty. See fencing penalty cards for how those work.

The Onishchenko scandal, Montreal 1976

The best-known cheating case in the sport involved Boris Onishchenko, a Soviet modern pentathlete, at the 1976 Montreal Olympics. In the épée portion of the modern pentathlon, his opponents noticed that his weapon was registering hits that did not appear to land. Officials examined the épée and found it had been modified so that a touch could be triggered without the tip being pressed. He was disqualified. The incident became a lasting symbol of cheating in the Olympics and prompted stricter inspection of electrical equipment.

Controversies that are not cheating

Some famous fencing controversies involve mistakes or disputes rather than dishonesty. At the 2012 London Olympics, a women’s épée semi-final ended in a long delay after a timing problem with the clock, which left a fencer in tears on the strip. That was a controversy over officiating, not cheating. In 2023, a dispute over a handshake at a World Championships bout led to a black card and a debate about sportsmanship rules. Again, those were disciplinary and procedural issues rather than rigging.

How officials catch cheating

  • Weapon and equipment checks. Weapons and wiring are tested before and during competitions. Officials can test a weapon’s tip pressure, check for hidden circuits and verify that kit meets the standard.
  • The referee. Fencing referees watch for off-target hits, unsafe actions and suspicious behaviour, and can halt the bout to investigate.
  • The scoring system. The electronic apparatus is designed so that a legitimate touch must show on the correct line for the correct duration, which makes simple tampering harder than in earlier eras.
  • Video review. At events with video review, officials can look back at an action. See video review in fencing.
  • Other fencers. As with Onishchenko, opponents who notice unusual behaviour may raise it with the referee.

What happens to a fencer caught cheating

The consequences depend on the offence and the rules for the event. Serious cases can result in a black card, disqualification from the competition and possible further sanctions from the federation. For more on this, see what a black card means in fencing.

What is not allowed in fencing

Beyond outright cheating, things that are not allowed include:

  • Hitting with excessive force or acting dangerously
  • Turning your back on the opponent in ways the rules forbid
  • Leaving the strip deliberately to delay play
  • Using equipment that fails the inspection
  • Disobeying or abusing officials

Cheating in other sports

Many sports have had their own equipment and rule-breaking scandals, from doctored balls to tampered gear. Fencing’s version is unusual because the scoring technology gives a technical route to cheating, and that same technology is also what makes inspection possible.

The complete guide to penalties and referees

Fencing Penalties: Yellow, Red and Black Cards
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →