What video review is
Video review lets officials look at a replay of an action to check or correct a decision. In fencing, it is normally used to help the referee with fast actions that are hard to read in real time. It supplements the referee; it does not replace them.
Where it is used
Video review is mostly found at higher-level competitions, such as major international events, and some national championships. It is typically limited to certain rounds, often direct elimination bouts. At club events and many regional tournaments there is no replay system, because it needs cameras, a video referee and extra equipment.
Rules differ by event and change over time, so check the technical rules or the event notice for the specific competition.
How a challenge works
At events that use review, a fencer can usually ask for a review of a referee’s decision. In general terms:
- The fencer signals that they want to challenge, usually right after the call and before the next action starts.
- The action is paused and the replay is examined.
- The decision is either confirmed or changed.
Rules commonly limit how many challenges each fencer has in a bout. At many events, a fencer keeps the challenge if it succeeds and loses it if it does not, which discourages unnecessary requests. The exact numbers and conditions come from the rulebook.
What can and cannot be reviewed
Review is most useful for questions of fact, for example whether a touch was on target or whether a fencer stepped off the strip. Subjective judgments, such as how a referee reads a phrase for right-of-way, are less clear cut and rules may restrict what can be reviewed. If you want to understand the calls that might be challenged, see fencing referee commands.
Who makes the decision
Depending on the setup, a separate video referee may watch the replay and advise, or the bout’s referee may review the footage and decide. The goal is to reach a more accurate decision without slowing the event down too much. For the main referee’s role, see fencing referees.
Why some events do not have it
Video review costs money and organisation, and it can slow down large tournaments with many bouts running at once. Many local events rely on the referee’s judgement, and any dispute goes through the normal channels described in can you appeal a fencing referee’s call.
Video review and cheating
Replays can also help officials check suspicious actions. Equipment checks and referees are still the main tools against cheating; see cheating in fencing.